How to Brief a Recruiter So They Find the Right Person
9 min readBy RecruiterLink

A vague brief gets a vague shortlist. Here is how to brief a recruiter so they find the right person: must-haves, salary, the pitch and a tight process.
You can hire a specialist recruiter who knows your market cold and still end up with a shortlist that misses the point. It happens more often than people admit, and the cause is on your side of the table: a thin, recycled or contradictory brief.
We have already written a practical guide to using a recruitment agency. This is the deep dive on the brief itself. The quality of that brief sets the ceiling on the search. Get it right and a good recruiter can talk to people who are not even looking. Get it wrong and you will spend weeks reviewing CVs that look busy and feel wrong.
Start with the legal floor, then go further
In the UK, this is not only good practice. Under regulation 18 of the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003, an agency may not introduce a candidate until it has enough information from you to select someone suitable. That includes who you are, the start date and likely duration, the type of work, location and hours, known health and safety risks, the experience and qualifications required (by you, by law or by a professional body), and any expenses. For a permanent role it also covers the minimum pay and benefits, pay intervals and the notice period. GOV.UK sets the same list out in plain English.
Treat that list as the floor, not the finished brief. A recruiter can legally make an introduction with those facts. They cannot sell your role, test for the work that matters, or give honest market feedback unless you go further.
Explain why the role exists, and what success looks like
A job description lists duties. A brief explains the job. Start with why you are hiring now. Is this a replacement, a new seat in a growing team, a move into a new market, or a fix for something that is not working? If it is a replacement, say what the last person did well and what you want done differently. If it is a new role, say what problem the hire will own, and who carries that work today.
Then describe success in concrete terms. What should be true after three months, and after a year? "Owns the relationship with our three largest accounts" is usable. "Is a self-starter" is not. Outcomes let the recruiter test candidates against real work rather than keywords. If two interviewers have different pictures of success, the search will drift. Settle it in the brief, not in the debrief.
Also say how the role sits in the team: who it reports to, who it manages, and who it has to influence without authority. Recruiters use that when they pitch the role to someone who already has a good job.
Keep the must-haves short, and mean it
This is where most briefs go wrong. A hiring manager copies last year's person specification, adds a few more tools, and ends up with twelve "essential" criteria. Every extra must-have shrinks the pool, and many strong people rule themselves out.
Official guidance is unusually clear. The CIPD's inclusive recruitment guide recommends having as few requirements as possible and making sure they are absolutely necessary for the role. It also advises describing observable behaviours rather than character traits: "you have presented findings to clients" rather than "you are a gifted communicator." GOV.UK guidance on inclusive job descriptions makes the same points: reduce long lists of must-haves, use open language such as "familiarity with," and list behaviours instead of vague traits.
A practical test helps. For each requirement, ask: would we reject an otherwise excellent candidate who lacked this on day one? If the answer is no, it belongs on the nice-to-have list. Licences, professional authorisations and skills that cannot be learned quickly are must-haves. A preferred tool, a particular industry background or "ten years in a similar business" usually is not.
Be equally careful with "cultural fit." The CIPD warns that this phrase is subjective and often means "someone like the people we already have." Tell the recruiter how the team actually operates and how decisions get made. A request for a "good cultural fit" is not a brief.
Give them a real salary range
Recruiters cannot sell a role they cannot price. In the UK, the minimum rate of pay is part of the information an agency must obtain before introducing anyone. Even where the law does not spell it out, a vague "competitive salary" wastes everyone's time.
Share the range, say how flexible it is, and be clear what sits inside it: base salary only, or bonus, allowances, superannuation, pension, a car or equity. If your budget is below the market, a good recruiter will tell you early. That is valuable, not an inconvenience. Listen, then decide whether to move the range, reshape the role, or accept a longer search.
Pay transparency is not only a courtesy to candidates. SHRM research published in 2023 found that 70% of organisations that listed pay ranges on job postings said it led to more applicants, and 66% said it increased the quality of applicants. Among workers surveyed, 82% were more likely to consider a job if the pay range was listed. You do not have to publish the range on a job board. You do have to give it to your recruiter if you want a serious search.
Give them a pitch, not just a list of duties
The best people for many roles are busy doing a good job somewhere else. They will not move for a bullet list. They will move for a story they believe: the problem they would get to solve, the team, the growth, the flexibility, the mission, or the chance to build something.
Write that pitch down, including the unpolished bits. If the team is small, say what that makes possible. If the product is early, say what has already been proven. If the role is demanding, be honest about the pace and the support around it. A recruiter who has to invent the story will invent a weaker one.
This is also the place for practical details people actually ask about: location and office days, travel, hours, flexible working, right to work, and start date. A late surprise on any of these can undo a month of good work.
Brief the process, not just the role
A great shortlist dies in a slow or confused process. Write down the interview stages, who sits on each one, what each stage is for, and how quickly you will give feedback. Name a single decision-maker. Agree how candidates should be presented, and how often you will speak while the search is live.
Keep the process lean. Every extra round lets a competitor make an offer first. If several people need to meet the candidate, use a single-day panel rather than three separate weeks. Decide that in the brief, not after the first CV arrives.
The people on the panel need to be briefed too. CIPD research has found that just 28% of UK employers train all interviewers on legal obligations and objective interview practice. If the panel is going to assess candidates against the brief, they need to have read it. Otherwise the recruiter will hear "not quite right" with no usable reason.
Say which trade-offs you will accept
Every hard search ends with a trade-off. Tell the recruiter in advance which ones you would consider: more pay for deeper experience, a longer notice period for a stronger candidate, a different location with more remote days, or a less senior hire with a development plan. If you will not move on salary, location or start date, say that too.
This lets the recruiter make judgement calls without waiting for a meeting, and it stops a strong but imperfect candidate being screened out early while the role stays open for another month.
Do it as a conversation, with the hiring manager in the room
A written brief is essential, and it is not enough on its own. The best briefings are conversations, and the hiring manager should be there, not only HR. Fifteen extra minutes at the start can save weeks later, because a good recruiter will test the brief as they hear it: which must-haves shrink the market, which parts of the pitch will land, and where your process is slower than the candidates you want.
Look for that challenge. A recruiter who accepts every requirement at face value is not doing their job. Once you have chosen a specialist, work with them as a partner rather than sending the role to a long list of firms and hoping for a race. We cover that choice in our employer's guide to using a recruitment agency, and it is worth reading the terms before you sign.
Keep the brief alive once the search starts
The brief is not finished when the meeting ends. The first few candidates are a test of whether it was clear. Give feedback fast, ideally within a day or two, and be specific: "not enough stakeholder experience" is useful, "not quite right" is not. If the market tells you something, or the role changes, update the brief and tell the recruiter immediately.
The same applies if you are also advertising the role yourself, or if an internal candidate appears. Keep the recruiter in the loop. Surprises damage trust, and they can create messy questions about introductions and fees, which we unpack in our guide to how recruitment agencies get paid.
The bottom line
A recruitment agency is only as good as the brief you give it. Write down why the role exists, what success looks like, the few things someone must have on day one, a real salary range, a pitch a busy person would care about, a lean process, and the trade-offs you will accept. Then talk it through with the hiring manager and the recruiter, and keep the brief up to date as evidence comes in.
If you do that, a good specialist has everything they need. If you are ready to find that specialist, start on RecruiterLink. Filter agencies by sector and location, compare firms in the United Kingdom, Australia or the United States that already know your market, or search for a specialism in a city. A clear brief, given to the right recruiter, is one of the highest-leverage things a hiring manager can do.
Sources
- The Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003, regulation 18
- GOV.UK, "Before placing a worker with a hirer"
- GOV.UK, "Make job descriptions inclusive"
- CIPD, "Inclusive recruitment: Guide for people professionals"
- SHRM, "New SHRM Research Shows Pay Transparency Makes Organizations More Competitive, Leads to Increase in Qualified Applicants"
- employers
- hiring
- recruitment agencies
- job brief
- hiring managers


